[ Login ]

Advertising

Last completed movie pages

Cinq colonnes à la une; My Eyes Are Up Here; ดาวพระศุกร์; Egyszer volt Budán Bödör Gáspár; Lie to Me; 東京ヴァンパイアホテル: 映画版; Secuestro al vuelo 601; Picasso Trigger; 破戰; The Prime Minister Is Missing; Zapomenuté světlo; Hell Squad; クレヨンしんちゃん 嵐を呼ぶ!夕陽のカスカベボーイズ; The In-Laws; Riding High; (more...)

Pressed Steel M4 'Sherman' Firefly conversion

Pressed Steel M4 'Sherman' in The Lords of Discipline, Movie, 1983 IMDB

Class: Others, Military armored vehicle — Model origin: US

Pressed Steel M4 'Sherman' Firefly conversion

[*] Background vehicle

Comments about this vehicle

AuthorMessage

mike962 DE

◊ 2021-10-07 15:33

 fake , it's a prop

Lateef NO

◊ 2021-10-07 15:38

 How can you tell?

mike962 DE

◊ 2021-10-07 16:12
Lateef wrote How can you tell?

all those wheels, chassie and tracks look fake

not at all like a real Sherman
Link to "www.thoughtco.com"

clearly notice the bottom wheels , they have no depth , the front wheel has no teeth either

-- Last edit: 2021-10-07 16:16:31

Lateef NO

◊ 2021-10-07 17:53

 It's a gate guard. These are not intended to be operable, hence the discrepancies of the chassis. The hull itself and turret appear real enough to me.

mike962 DE

◊ 2021-10-07 18:06
Lateef wrote It's a gate guard. These are not intended to be operable, hence the discrepancies of the chassis. The hull itself and turret appear real enough to me.

the gun doesn't really fit either

long with muzzle brake would suggest "Easy 8" variant but that one had the Horizontal Volute Spring Suspension and a different turret

Link to "www.tanks-encyclopedia.com"

here all original US sherman variants http://the.shadock.free.fr/sherman_minutia/index.html

you can exclud A1 as it's welded , A2 never was used in US service, A4 has the extended hull which this one doesn't , that leaves it just with orignal or A3 variant possible and doesn't fit with either


-- Last edit: 2021-10-07 18:12:06

Lateef NO

◊ 2021-10-07 18:12

 What makes you think it's an American Sherman? This was shot in the UK and could be a Sherman Firefly, for instance.

mike962 DE

◊ 2021-10-07 18:19

 well in that case I would go with Pressed Steel M4 "Sherman" Firelfy conversion as the most likely thing since more variants had firefly conversions



http://the.shadock.free.fr/sherman_minutia/sherman_types/m4/m4.html

-- Last edit: 2021-10-07 18:22:55

mike962 DE

◊ 2021-10-07 18:21

 Three different variants of Sherman Firefly served during the Second World War, each based on a different variant of the M4 Sherman. The Firefly conversion was carried out on Sherman I (M4), Sherman I Hybrid (M4 Composite) and Sherman V (M4A4) tanks. Some sources state that several Sherman IIs (M4A1) were converted and used in action, but photos allegedly showing these conversions are in fact views of the front half of Sherman I Hybrid Fireflies.[citation needed] To complicate matters, a very small number of Canadian licence-built Sherman IIs (M4A1), the Grizzly, were converted to Fireflies in Canada and used for training, but none saw action

mike962 DE

◊ 2021-10-07 18:24

 or maybe it's a longer Chrysler M4 A4 but the longer gap is not as visible with the fake wheels

[Image: m4a4_5.1.jpg]

-- Last edit: 2021-10-07 18:25:07

GodzillaFan54 CA

◊ 2021-10-07 21:47

 You sure know your tanks!

mike962 DE

◊ 2021-12-23 16:45
Lateef wrote It's a gate guard. These are not intended to be operable, hence the discrepancies of the chassis. The hull itself and turret appear real enough to me.


there is another major inconsistency with a real Sherman, that side plate , never seen it mounted that high on real Sherman , back wheel also way too low

[Image: untitled.6036.jpg]

Add a comment

You must login to post comments...

Advertising

Watch or buy this title - Powered by JustWatch

Advertising